Human vs AI: Who Wins in Writing?

 

by David Singer

It’s hard to imagine students decades ago. Hours in libraries, handwritten notes, long nights over textbooks. Well, ChatGPT has radically changed life in academia. Now, all the answers are at hand, essays are written in just a few seconds and it seems that studying has become easier. But is it true?
In fact, AI detectors are improving every day and every educational institution strives to have the best equipment to bring students to light. Some try to rewrite AI texts manually, but it doesn’t help. So, it’s not surprising that AI has created such a resonance in the academic field. It is a threat to academic integrity and the quality of the learning process.

Is AI effective and safe? It often makes up facts and professors easily notice it. We have a great alternative to AI - EssayPro - and in this guide, we compare the pros and cons of human or bot writing.

How Does ChatGPT Work?

Let's get to the main question. Where does ChatGPT get its information from? In other words, how does it create texts and how can you tell if it’s human or bot generated?

Text learning

First, the model "reads" billions of books, articles, and other sources to learn how people use language. It understands which words often go together, which sentences are logical, and how to build answers.

Word prediction

When you write a query or question, ChatGPT analyzes this text and tries to "guess" which word or phrase should logically follow. It does this very quickly, creating coherent and natural text.

Response

After that, it forms the response that matches your query, taking the context and style into account.
ChatGPT doesn’t "understand" information like a person, but works according to patterns and statistics.

What Can AI Offer Students?

  1. Saves time. ChatGPT analyzes tons of information and saves time and energy by helping students with complex and voluminous tasks. The eternal bot or human question has never been more relevant;
  2. Free to use. Modern AI models are available in free versions, which is great for a student budget. Even the paid versions are quite cost-effective. This is where the technology behind the bot or human debate becomes fascinating;
  3. Highlights key ideas. Thanks to advanced algorithms and the ability to analyze large sets of data, chat can quickly summarize the main points, making the human or AI choice more relevant than ever.

Main Limitations of ChatGPT

It's fast and free, it analyzes tons of information - what else do you need? However, the disadvantages of AI are outweighed by the advantages. Therefore, the promises made by AI models sound more pleasant than the harsh reality.

  1. AI has many limitations in contrast to a human easy writer. Chat lacks critical thinking and can’t offer emotional feedback on a specific topic. This is especially noticeable in reflective essays or any work where you need to share your experience, formulate a thesis and argue for it;
  2. Texts generated by AI don’t pass academic checks and are easily flagged by detectors. Using an AI checker essay tool alongside ensures that the content meets academic standards, whether it’s produced by human or robot methods or purely by AI;
  3. Mistakes and fabricated facts, outdated information. Human authors cite the latest research and up-to-date information. Instead, ChatGPT can fabricate statistics and facts, even the references themselves. This immediately makes any work a failure;
  4. If there was any bias present in the training datasets, AI can unintentionally repeat it in your text;
  5. Repetition, the same sentence structure, lack of originality. ChatGPT can focus on the number of words to be achieved rather than on the quality of the text itself. And here, the AI or human difference becomes obvious;
  6. Lack of creativity. ChatGPT offers you what is in the databases, it can’t create a unique solution on its own. And this is immediately noticed by teachers.

Risks of Using ChatGPT in College

ChatGPT raises many safety concerns, especially those related to data privacy and intellectual property. The main danger is to fall under the watchful eye of AI-detecting software. By the way, sometimes even rewritten content is detected as written by AI. Therefore, you need to be as careful as possible. If AI is found in your work, it leads to:

  1. Accusations of plagiarism;
  2. Low grades;
  3. Damaged reputation;
  4. Expulsion.

What Makes the Human Approach Stand Out?

Yes, ChatGPT can help in achieving short-term goals, for example, by suggesting a work structure or collecting key points from a textbook. It is fast and cost-efficient. However, these advantages are offset by a long list of pitfalls and risks.

That’s why more and more students turn to seasoned authors who have vast experience and understanding of nuances. In the ongoing debate of human writing vs AI writing, it’s easy to see why the human side still wins in many academic scenarios. Time-tested services help with tasks on any topic, of any complexity. People have something that AI can’t generate:

  1. Understanding the context. The AI interacts with the prompt you give. The more details you mention, the better the output will be. However, it won’t understand subtleties outside of the prompt. A person will approach the task from all perspectives: cultural, ethical, and political, and will choose an approach that will be ideal for your paper. This is one of the main AI writing vs human writing differences;
  2. Emotional response and personal reasoning. A person can rely on their background, as they have a specific vision. AI has no emotions or deep personal experience. That's why AI texts are so neutral. Teachers easily notice when the work lacks the warmth of human writing;
  3. Unique creative approach. If you need a fresh look at a situation or an innovative solution, it is the human author who will help you with this. AI is very analytical - it comes from existing data and familiar patterns. A human can come up with something that isn’t in the existing frameworks, producing truly human written text.
  4. Fact-checking. We have already mentioned that the ChatGPT often makes up facts. It can misinterpret information. In contrast, a person double-checks the facts and comes from their own experience, delivering truly human written work.

Possible Disadvantages of Human Writing

Of course, nothing is perfect, and there are two sides to every coin:

  1. Time. There are services that can write a paper for you in 3 hours, like EssayPro, but people can’t write a text in a couple of seconds. In contrast, ChatGPT is fast, but of poor quality;
  2. Price. ChatGPT is cost-free, but you have to pay for good quality human work. Although the prices are quite loyal, especially if you place an order in advance or use some discounts.

So the limitations are more technical than related to quality.

AI vs Human Intelligence Comparison

  1. Speed. AI writes in seconds, but the result is of poor quality. Humans write in several hours, days, but the quality is worth it;
  2. Price. AI is free, some versions are inexpensive. You pay for human work per page, but the prices are still affordable;
  3. Quality. AI writes with repetitions and mistakes. A human writes authentically and vividly;
  4. Originality. AI has zero originality. A human writes according to your requirements and gives a report on originality;
  5. Data privacy and intellectual property. Here, AI can’t guarantee anything. But time-tested services such as EssayPro protect your privacy and payments. You will have an originality report and if the work doesn’t satisfy you, you will get your money back.

From this AI intelligence vs human intelligence perspective, it’s clear that human authors remain the safest and most reliable assistant in college.